Welcome DMs

How to send an automatic Substack DM to new free subscribers, paid subscribers and new followers from the DMs page, what each of the 4 setup steps does, the daily limit per plan, the extension version it needs, and how to pause it.

Welcome DMs send an automatic direct message on Substack to people who just subscribed to your newsletter or followed you. You set them up on the DMs page (titled Direct Messages) in four steps: who gets one, when it goes out, what it says and how many go out a day. They need the Standard or Enterprise plan and the browser extension 1.5.8 or newer.

How it works

  • DMs are sent from your own Substack account by the browser extension. They only send while your browser is open. The page says: "Any missed while it's closed don't roll over."
  • Only people who join after you turn auto-DMs on get one. Nobody on your current list does.
  • Each newsletter you have has its own setup. If you have more than one, they show as tabs at the top. Use the Newsletters menu to hide or show a newsletter.
  • New followers and the daily limit are shared by all your newsletters. They are tagged All newsletters.
  • A reader only ever gets one welcome DM from you, even if they join more than one of your newsletters.

Steps

  1. Open DMs in the sidebar (under Engage).
  2. Pick the newsletter tab, if you have more than one.
  3. Step 1, Who gets a welcome DM. Switch on Free subscribers, Paid subscribers and New followers as you like.
    • Skip readers you already chat with (on by default): no welcome DM if you already have a conversation with them.
  4. Step 2, When it goes out. In Send it, choose Right away (the default), 15 minutes, 1 hour, 3 hours, 1 day, 2 days, 3 days or 7 days. The wait counts from when the reader joins.
  5. Step 3, What it says. Each audience has its own tab and message. Edit the text and click Save. The preview next to it shows the message To Sara and To a reader with no name.
  6. Step 4, How many a day. Type a number in Up to … DMs a day and click Save. Under it, Today shows how many were sent, how many are left and how many are waiting in line.
  7. Click Turn on auto-DMs at the top. The badge next to the newsletter name changes to Live.

Changes to the switches and Send it save right away. Messages and the daily limit need Save.

To send the waiting DMs without waiting for the next run, click Run now next to Last run at the top. While it runs, it shows Sending now.

Personalize the message

ButtonWhat it adds
{name}The reader's first name, or "there" when they don't have one
Insert condition{{ name ? 'Hey {name},' : 'Hey,' }}: the first wording when the reader has a name, the second when they don't

WriteStack checks whether each reader's name looks like a real name. Brands, handles and blank names count as no name.

Welcome new followers

Turn on New followers in step 1, then write their message in the New followers tab in step 3. These are people who follow you on Substack without subscribing.

  • A follower waits at least 4 hours. If they subscribe in that time, they get the subscriber message instead.
  • Only people who follow you after you switch it on get a DM. People who followed while it was off, or more than 7 days ago, don't.
  • Followers you already chat with are always skipped.
  • Substack only shares up to 10 names per follow notification. When more people follow at once, WriteStack can't welcome the rest. The page shows how many it missed in the last 30 days.
  • The New followers card shows how many were sent and how many are waiting.

Follower DMs need extension 1.5.32 or newer. With an older extension, the card says "Update the WriteStack extension to welcome new followers."

Pause DMs

Click Pause DMs at the top. The badge changes to Paused. Click Turn on auto-DMs to start again.

New followers don't wait for Turn on auto-DMs: they get a DM as soon as their switch is on. If only New followers is on, the top of the page shows Live, and Pause DMs pauses follower DMs. When follower DMs are switched back on, people who followed while they were paused don't get one.

BadgeMeaning
LiveDMs are going out
PausedFree or paid subscribers are switched on, but auto-DMs are paused
OffNo audience is switched on

Limits

HobbyistStandardEnterprise
Welcome DMsNot includedIncludedIncluded
Most DMs a dayNot included3050
SettingValue
Lowest daily limit1
Highest daily limitYour plan's maximum
Longest wait before sending7 days
Message lengthUp to 2,000 characters
Follower wait to see if they subscribe4 hours
Oldest follow that still gets a DM7 days
  • The daily limit is one number for all your newsletters and new followers together. Subscribers go first. Followers only get the slots left over.
  • The day resets at midnight in your WriteStack timezone.
  • On Hobbyist, the DMs page shows Unlock Welcome DMs with an Upgrade Now button. See Plans and limits.
FeatureMinimum extension version
Welcome DMs1.5.8
Welcome DMs on a custom domain1.5.17
Welcome DMs to new followers1.5.32

If it doesn't work

ProblemFix
"Update the WriteStack extension"Update the extension, then refresh the page. See Install the browser extension.
"Connect your publication"Click Connect publication and connect your newsletter. See Connect your Substack.
Turn on auto-DMs can't be clickedSwitch on free or paid subscribers in step 1 first
"Turn on free or paid subscribers first"Same: switch on at least one subscriber audience in step 1
"Chrome needs access to your-domain.com to send welcome DMs" (or Firefox, Edge…)Your newsletter is on a custom domain. Click Allow and accept the browser prompt. In Firefox, click Allow access in the WriteStack tab that opens.
"Unfinished condition…"A {{ … }} condition is missing a quote or brace. Use the format {{ name ? 'Hey {name},' : 'Hey,' }}.
"No newsletter shown"You hid every newsletter. Show one from the Newsletters menu.
DMs stopped for the dayYou reached your daily limit. More go out after midnight.
DMs didn't go out overnightThey only send while your browser is open with the extension

On this page